You can't make a ranking that way ......

Nov 19, 2008,18:30 PM
 

... if you don't define your criterias very precisely.

Generally spoken, i.e. all merits included, I'd rather arrange the brands in groups, for instance (in random order):

Traditional manufacturers at the very top:
Lange, PP, VC, AP and Breguet

Ditto, close behind:
JLC, GO, Girard-P, Blancpain, IWC - maybe also Chopard L.U.C., Droz and UN

High-end sport:
Rolex, Panerai, Hublot, IWC

Special manufacturers / independents:
Journe, Genta, Roth, Mille, Winston, Smith, Voutilainen and some more

And then you have some fine manufacturers like Omega and Seiko with a wide range of watches from the very cheap to high-end competitive.

And a closer inspection on specific watches mixes removes many borders. The Three-Bridges from GP, the Grand Complication from IWC, many JLCs are not lesser than any of the first group. And the "specials" can beat anyone with particular watches - Journe for instance.

Sven



More posts: Voutilainen

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Top 12 Brands ???

 
 By: jm_spns : November 18th, 2008-17:57
1. PP 2. VACHERON C 3. BREGUET 4. AUDEMARS PIGUET 5. JLC 6. GIRARD PERREGAUX 7. A LANGE S 8. GLASHUTTE 9. ULYSSE N 10.BLANCPAIN 11. ROLEX 12. HUBLOT

and IWC ??? [nt]

 
 By: jespinosa : November 18th, 2008-18:10

My list (any order)

 
 By: mr_vgs : November 18th, 2008-18:18
PP, AP, BREGET, JLC, GP, ROLEX, GO, A LANGE S, IWC, ULYSSE N, VACHERON C, BLANCPAIN

and OP??

 
 By: harlim : November 18th, 2008-18:30

my 8

 
 By: rijowysock : November 18th, 2008-18:36

Based on what?

 
 By: BDLJ : November 18th, 2008-20:43

12 is tough . . . here are my Top ___ . . .

 
 By: Craig LA : November 18th, 2008-20:56
My personal “Top Manufacturers” in alphabetical order: A. Lange & Sohne / Audemars Piguet / Breguet / Christopher Claret / Felix Baumgartner / F.P. Journe / Greubel Forsey / Harry Winston Opus / HD3 / Jaeger LeCoultre / Jean Dunard / Kari Voutilainen / Pa... 

here's my top 12 Swiss Brands

 
 By: Cookies : November 18th, 2008-21:07

For me it's useless...

 
 By: foversta : November 19th, 2008-11:50

My top 12

 
 By: mikethw : November 19th, 2008-20:27

My list (a first attempt)

 
 By: pausanias : November 29th, 2008-11:28